Political Polarization and Individualized Online Information Environments: A Longitudinal Tracking Study (POLTRACK)

What is the interplay between the diversity of our information exposure online and the polarization of our political opinions towards certain issues or groups over time?

The online information environment provides citizens with an abundance of news and other content relevant for political opinion formation that varies considerably in terms of journalistic quality and political extremity.

Politicians, journalists and academics have speculated that by facilitating individualized processes of opinion formation, the current high-choice environment of online news websites, social media and other information intermediaries is related to audience fragmentation and political polarization.

Yet, research on the interplay of media exposure and dynamic polarization processes is sparse and at times contradictory. One of the reasons is that methods traditionally employed by social scientists to measure exposure such as sur-vey-based self-reports inadequately capture online behavior.

Data Collection

We therefore choose a different approach in the three-year cooperation project with the Universities of Bremen and Constance and the GESIS – Leibniz Institute for the Social Sciences. Our project brings together techniques from computational social science with theories and methods from communication and political science. At its core is a yearlong web tracking of a representative sample of approximately 1,500 German citizens from an online access panel. The participants are surveyed on demographics, political opinions, and media use in five waves and consent to having their visited websites tracked. Through automated crawling and text analysis of those website contents, we are able to measure the source, issue, and actor diversity of the information participants are exposed to and relate that to the development of their political opinions over time.

With this longitudinal data, we systematically study the interplay between online information use and political opinions by statistically disentangling within-person changes. On an aggregated level, we answer questions about audience fragmentation and the absolute and shifting levels of issue-based and affective polarization. Findings have implications for academic and political debates on echo chambers, societal cohesion, and the regulation of online environments.

The three-year project was funded as part of the Leibniz Competition Collaborative Excellence by the Leibniz Institute for Media Research as the applicant in collaboration with the cooperation partners in Cologne, Bremen and Constance.

Participants in the study will receive legally required information on data protection and the joint responsibility of the participating research institutions in accordance with Art. 26 para. 2 sentence 2 GDPR here (pdf).

Photo by Wendy Wei on Pexels

Project details

Overview

Start of the term: ; End of term: 2025

Research programme: RP 1 Transformation of Public Communication

Persons involved

Contact person

Lisa Merten

Dr. Lisa Merten

Postdoc Researcher Media Use & Digital Communication

Leibniz Institute for Media Research | Hans-Bredow-Institut (HBI)
Rothenbaumchaussee 36
20148 Hamburg
Germany

Similar projects & publications

Cover of the journal "Rechtstheorie"
Contribution to Legal Theory

On Tendencies towards the Multiplication and Dynamization of Law

In his article with the original German title "Von Kelsen zu Castells? Zu Tendenzen der Vervielfältigung und Dynamisierung des Rechts" in the journal Rechtstheorie, Tobias Mast deals with structural changes in the legal system and the actors involved.

Cover of the article "Interdisciplinary Architecture Modeling for Regulating Digital Business Ecosystems"
Interdisciplinary Architecture Modeling

Regulating Digital Business Ecosystems

This paper explores the question of how complex socio-technical ecosystems can be modeled using architectural methods.

Cover of the journal GRUR
Published now

Platform Law as EU Law

In his article in GRUR Int., Tobias Mast describes the peculiarities of platform law, which has been developing at European level for several years.

Hand tippt auf Smartphone
How do software systems affect user behavior?

Software Systems, the Public and Participation

The aim of this project is to develop a communication-sociological approach to the relationship between software systems, the public sphere and participation.

Fußspuren im Sand
Collaborative Project

Political Polarization and Online Information Environments

What is the interplay between the diversity of our information exposure online and the polarization of our political opinions towards certain issues or groups over time?

Lichtinstallation: Weiße Quader schweben in dunkelblauem Raum
Volkswagen Foundation Funds Joint Project

Informing Regulatory Reasoning on Algorithmic Systems in Societal Communication with STEAM

The project, which is located between media law and computer science, aims to use a new method to visualize the functioning of news distribution on digital platforms and thus offer media regulation opportunities for new regulatory approaches.

Äpfel in einer Sortiermaschine
New Methods in Automated Content Analysis

Few-Shot Learning in Communication Science

The cooperation project transfers computer science methods to empirical communication science. Semi-automated content analyses can thus also examine vast amounts of data.

Schloss Schwerin
Telephone Survey

Media Use and Political Culture in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania

The study aims to provide an overview of politically oriented media use and political culture in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern as well as to develop strategies to improve outreach to population groups that largely avoid news.

Zeitung, Notizbuch mit Stift, Mobiltelefon, Kaffeebecher und Sonnenbrill auf einem Holztisch
International Study on News Usage

Reuters Institute Digital News Report

The annual international representative survey conducted by the Reuters Institute in Oxford examines news usage and reveals general trends and national characteristics of developments. The Leibniz Institute for Media Research is conducting the German part of the study.

Mensch steht auf grauem Grund in der Mitte einer runden Spielfeldmarkierung. Er wirft einen langen Schatten.
Human in the Machine

Human In the Loop? Autonomy and Automation in Socio-Technical Systems

The research project Human in the Loop? investigates how human participation can improve automated decision-making processes.

1 2 3

Page 1 from 3

Newsletter

Information about current projects, events and publications of the institute.

Subscribe now