Informing Regulatory Reasoning on Algorithmic Systems in Societal Communication with STEAM

The project, which is located between media law and computer science, aims to use a new method to visualize the functioning of news distribution on digital platforms and thus offer media regulation opportunities for new regulatory approaches.

Societal communication has changed profoundly in the wake of ongoing digitalisation. As new players are active and algorithmic systems as well as other technologies are used, new approaches to media regulation may also be required. While the ideal of maintaining media diversity has been the primary concern so far, it is now no longer scarce channels but complex systems of the most diverse actors that determine what chance a certain content has of being perceived.

Researchers from the Universität Hamburg and the Leibniz Institute for Media Research are developing a new so-called “Socio-Technical Ecosystem Architecture Method” (STEAM) using the case studies “Facebook” or “Facebook News” and the American social networking platform “Parler”.

The method being developed will provide a holistic view of news dissemination in an ecosystem such as that of news dissemination on Facebook, and will help to map these ecosystems with their relationships between actors, data flows and software components in such a way that problems can be identified and, if necessary, provide linkage opportunities for new regulatory approaches.

The project is one of seven project consortia from the social and technical sciences funded by the Volkswagen Foundation. All selected projects are scheduled to run for three to four years and will each receive funding of around 1.5 million euros. Further information on the Volkswagen Foundation’s initiative “Artificial Intelligence and the Society of the Future”.

Development of the Method

The project aims to develop a socio-technical ecosystem architecture methodology. This methodology builds on existing architecture concepts in computer science and complements them with normative concepts as well as frameworks with a legal and ethical background and horizon scanning approaches. This allows for a holistic description of an ecosystem, its actors and its action dynamics, and reveals risks to public communication as well as suitable starting points for counteracting them in a regulatory way.

Novel actors and technologies used by them, particularly related to artificial intelligence (AI), have gained relevance in the generation, aggregation, selection, curation, and prioritization of content. At the time a content item is displayed in an individual’s sphere of attention, numerous decisions are made beforehand that influence the content’s dissemination and the probability of ending up as part of the individual’s media repertoire. Specifically, various actors (e.g. content creators, digital platforms or content providers) involved in the entire process from content creation to content provision have influence on societal communication. In this relation, these actors also increasingly use algorithmic systems and, in particular, AI. Two examples illustrate this phenomenon:

  1. The first illustrative example is provided by Facebook and its news-aggregating application Facebook News. The platform is constituted by a constellation of human, technical, and institutional actors and dynamics as well as interdependencies among them. Ultimately, human curators, together with recommendation and filtering algorithms, generate a selection of media contributions that are offered to the user. However, the pool of available contributions is already narrowed by various limiting factors in the broader environment. Facebook, together with external partners, selects media outlets that are admitted. Furthermore, Facebook determines publisher guidelines that providers need to adhere to and monetization schemes that publishers need to agree to. Therefore, the media repertoire of a user of Facebook News is co-determined by a range of decisions made by various actors.
  2. The second example considers the American social networking platform Parler, which is often discussed for user content involving far-right posts, antisemitism, and conspiracy theories. In January 2021, three companies exerted meaningful influence on the accessibility and usage of Parler. Both major mobile platform providers – Google and Apple – removed Parler from their respective app stores on iOS and Android. In addition, Amazon excluded Parler from its cloud hosting service Amazon Web Services (AWS). Through this intervention by Amazon, Parler was apparently unable to operate its platform and had to go offline. The example emphasizes that  parties who fulfil different functions in making content accessible have an influence on what content is brought to the attention of users without prior judicial or regulatory decision to do so and without having been in the spotlight as important actors in societal communication.

Both cases demonstrate challenges to pre-existing mechanisms for safeguarding societal communication and its essential functions. The cases might hint at problems for relevant qualities of societal communication, which are not covered by the current communication law system. Therefore, we need to fundamentally rethink how we can continue to ensure that socially relevant communication takes place both openly and freely.

To achieve the research objectives, we develop the Socio-Technical Ecosystem Architecture Method (STEAM) to enable a holistic view on news dissemination in an ecosystem. This method will help in the presentation of ecosystems and their actors and relations in a way that forms the basis from a regulatory perspective to allow the assessment of the potential influence of actors. To develop STEAM, we integrate architectural thinking and normative reasoning within three iterations of a design science research (DSR) appraoch.

Photo by fabio on Unsplash

Project details

Overview

Start of the term: 2022; End of term: 2026

Third-party funder

Volkswagen Foundation

Co-operation partners

  • Prof. Dr. Tilo Böhmann
  • Prof. Dr. Ingrid Schirmer
  • Prof. Dr. Judith Simon (alle Fachbereich Informatik, Universität Hamburg)

Contact person

Wolfgang Schulz

Prof. Dr. Wolfgang Schulz

Scientific Director (Chairperson)

We are no longer located at Rothenbaumchaussee 36. You can reach us temporarely at the following address:

Leibniz Institute for Media Research, Hans-Bredow-Institut
c/o betahaus | Gänsemarkt
Gänsemarkt 43
20354 Hamburg

Similar projects & publications

Cover of the M&K journal, issue 3/2025
Publikation M&K 3/2025 as Special Issue

Diversity, Intersectionality, and Gender in Journalism

The third issue of M&K in 2025 is a special edition on "Diversity, Intersectionality, and Gender in Journalism," edited by Margreth Lünenborg, Ana-Nzinga Weiß, Yener Bayramoğlu, and Bernadette Uth. The nine articles are available open access on the Nomos eLibrary.

Cover of an article by Judith Möller et al. in the journal
Publikation Article in Journal of Communication

Positioning and Presentation of Articles in News Aggregators

In the study “Nudges for News Recommenders,” Dr. Nicolas Mattis, Lucien Heitz, Dr. Philipp K. Masur, Prof. Dr. Judith Möller, and Prof. Dr. Wouter van Atteveldt examine how the placement and presentation of environmental news in news aggregators can influence user behavior.

Cover of the Oxford Handbook
Publikation Digital Orders of the Future

Digital Constitutionalism Rethought

In a chapter of the Oxford Handbook of Digital Constitutionalism, Matthias C. Kettemann and Anna Sophia Tiedeke explore digital constitutionalism from the perspective of various normativities. These are the diverse rules, values, and organizing principles that shape the digital space.

Eine hübsche junge Familie aus Vater, Mutter Kind blicken strahlend in die Kamera, im Vordergrund links ein Ringlicht
Projekt Project for State Media Authorities

Babies and Toddlers as Family Influencers

The HBI is conducting a qualitative and quantitative study to examine how babies and young children under the age of five are portrayed on commercial German-language 'family influencing' profiles on Instagram, TikTok and YouTube. A team led by Dr. Claudia Lampert and Dr. Stephan Dreyer is discussing the findings in relation to the existing legal framework and media ethics considerations.

Cover des Buchs "Recht der Digitalisierung"
Publikation Available Open Access

Law of Digitalization

Can the right legal framework meet the central challenges of digitization? This volume, edited by Prof. Dr. Matthias C. Kettemann, explores important new areas of law, the regulation of AI, the role of digital services, and the characteristics of effective technology policy and sensible innovation law.

Screenshot der ersten "Seite" des Artikels auf dem Verfassungsblog
Publikation Article on Verfassungsblog

DSA Enforcement by the EU Commission

The problematic role of the European Commission in enforcing the Digital Services Act (DSA) and possible alternatives are the focus of a blog post published by Jan-Ole Harfst, Dr. Tobias Mast, and Prof. Dr. Wolfgang Schulz on 16 July 2025 on the Verfassungblog.

Cover der Zeitschrift
Publikation Recently Published

Community Data Trust for Sensitive Data

Jan Rau, Moritz Fürneisen, and Gregor Wiedemann co-developed the concept of community data stewardship to facilitate the collaborative creation and utilization of sensitive data in communication science. By using the example of research into right-wing extremist online communication, they demonstrate how community data stewardship can be structured.

Cover der Zeitschrift UFITA
Publikation Recently Published

On the Public Value of Public Service Media

"What Can Audience Research findings tell us about the public value of public service media?" This question explored by Prof. Dr. Uwe Hasebrink and PD Dr. Jan-Hinrik Schmidt, who published their insights in the issue 2/2024 of the journal UFITA.

Cover of the journal New Media & Society
Publikation Open Access Publication

Personal Preferences When Searching for Political Information

Lisa Merten and five co-authors researched how personality traits and attitudes affect the search for political information. Their article has now been published open access in the journal New Media & Society.

Cover der Broschüre zum 75. Geburtstag
Publikation Brochure Available for Download

Facets of 75 Years Hans-Bredow-Institut

With this brochure. we take a look at the institute's development since 1950. While we do not claim to provide a complete history, we aim to highlight some of the institute's unique characteristics, showcasing moments in the past when these features were particularly evident.

1 2 3 10

Page 1 from 10

Newsletter

Information about current projects, events and publications of the institute.

Subscribe now